No. 1:25-cv-13165

10/05/2025: DOJ filed motion to stay in light of the government shutdown, to which the State plaintiffs did not consent.

9/30/2025: Briefing schedule set; Response to Preliminary Injunction due 10/8, reply due 10/15, oral argument set for 10/16/2025.

8/20/2025: District Ct. hearing

6/10/2025: Motion for PI filed

7/7/2025: California joins the lawsuit and parties file an amended complaint

7/11/2025: Plaintiffs withdraw Motion for a Preliminary Injunction after Defendants agree not to sell Forced Reset Triggers (FRTs) in Plaintiff states. However, they will still be available in other states.

08/07/2025: Defendant Opposition to Motion for Preliminary Injunction Due

08/13/2025: Hearing on Preliminary Injunction (Order and Details Pending)

07/31/2025: Hearing on Motion for Preliminary Injunction

07/25/2025: Hearing is set for August 13

07/15/2025: Updated Schedule on Motion for Preliminary Injunction issued

07/25/2025: Defendant Opposition Due

07/30/2025: Plaintiff Reply

08/15/2025: Case Management Conference scheduled

No. 1:25-cv-12118

No. 3:25-cv-06310

10/31/2025: Case Management Conference

7/2/2025: Motion for Preliminary Injunction Filed Hearing scheduled for 9/5

07/17/2025: Briefing Schedule Filed in the District Court

08/06/2025: Defendant Opposition to Motion for Preliminary Injunction Due

08/15/2025: Plaintiff Reply Due

09/05/2025: Preliminary Injunction Hearing

No. 1:25-cv-11816

07/28/2025: District Court files Scheduling Order:

08/04/2025: Plaintiff Motion for Summary Judgment Due

The motion seeks, for Delaware, preservation in $687,091.48 in grants to the University of Delaware and the revocation of the 15% cap on the costs of indirect research, which would have cost the University of Delaware $9 million

After NSF agreed not to impose the 15% cap on the indirect costs of research The court denied the motion during the pendency of the litigation, the court denied that aspect of the motion for preliminary injunction.

The Court decided that the claims regarding the challenged grants (as compared to the issues regarding the indirect cost rate cap) had to be brought in the Court of Federal Claims.

08/01/2025: Preliminary Injunction Denied.

Relief in the next column relates to the vacatur of the cap on indirect costs of research. It will remain in place becuase it was granted in a different case. “

No. 25-1495 (1st Circuit)

08/08/2025: Plaintiff states file Motion to Vacate the Preliminary Injunction and schedule a status conference to discuss final judgment on the merits.

08/22/2025: Defendant Answer Due after extension granted on 08/01/2025

07/14/2025: United States Supreme Court stayed the preliminary injunction

7/14/2025: The Supreme Court of the United States Stayed the District Court’s injunction, permitting terminations to proceed pending appeals

No. 25-1671 (First Cir.)

Preliminary Injunction entered 5/16/2025, but it seemed to give the government leave to cancel the grants again with 14 days notice. The Government immediately issued that notice and tried to cut the grants again.

On 5/16/2025, the Judge said he would enter a new TRO against that, with brefing for a further PI to be completed by 6/3/2025

On 7/15/2025, the Def. appealed to the First Circuit.

07/30/2025: First Circuit grants Defendants Voluntary Motion to Dismiss Appeal of Preliminary Injunction.

08/12/2025: In the District Court, an extension is granted to Defendants to Answer the Amended Complaint, order pending.

07/18/2025: Defendant Motion to Vacate the Preliminary Injunction in light of the CASA decision rejected.

07/25/2025: Plaintiff Response to Motion to Clarify Preliminary Injunction Filed

08/13/2025: The District Court issued an Order Clarifying the Preliminary Injunction, narrowing its scope to only six of the agency’s centers from the order. The original lawsuit cited over 10,000 possible firings and after this, thousands of people will still likely lose their jobs despite the lawsuit.

06/19/2025: Preliminary Injunction granted and Stay pending appeal denied.

07/17/2025: Plaintiff’s Motion to Modify Preliminary Injunction to include the District of Columbia and Kentucky granted.

08/19/2025: Parties to file cross-motions to dismiss and for summary judgment

09/24/2025: Parties to file Responses to above

6/2/2025: Motion for PI filed on

6/6/2025: Response in opposition of PI filed

7/2/2025: Amended Complaint and Motion for Summary Judgement filed

7/23/2025: Def. Motion for Summary Judgement and Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgement filed

09/29/2025: District Court grants the state plaintiffs summary judgment on all claims

10/14/2025: District Court grants a motion to enforce the order for summary judgment

First Cir. No. 25-1726

The government has filed a motion to stay or transfer the case to D. D.C. We filed an opposition on 5/7/2025. The Court denied the motion to stay on 5/9/2025.

Preliminary Injunction granted 6/13/2025.

07/18/2025: Preliminary Injunction modified because of CASA decision, limiting certain relief to the Plaintiff States only.

07/31/2025: Defendants have appealed to the first circuit.

07/18/2025: Preliminary Injunction modified because of CASA decision, limiting certain relief to the Plaintiff States only.

Oral Argument on our motion for Preliminary Injunction is set for 6/17/2025

07/23/2025: Court grants Motion to Intervene for environmental public interest organizations, including Sierra Club, National Resources Defense Council (NRDC), and others.

08/01/2025: Plaintiff Reply Due

08/11/2025: Defendant Reply Due

No. 25-1813 (Fed. Circuit of Appeals)

Permanent Injunction entered 5/28/2025

The Government filed an appeal with the Federal Circuit and motion for a stay pending appeal in the Court of International Trade on 5/28/2025

On 5/29/2025, The Federal Circuit entered an administrative stay of the injunction pending briefing on the motion to stay

07/31/2025: Oral Argument heard in the Federal Circuit

08/29/2025: Federal Circuit Affirms the judgment of the lower court.

05/06/2025: Motion for Preliminary Injunction filed

06/05/2025: Preliminary Injunction granted

07/24/2025: Amended Complaint Filed, adding the Office of Management and Budget as a defendant

08/04/2025: Filed second motion for Preliminary Injunction

08/28/2025: OMB agrees to release FY2025 appropriated funds that it had held back from AmeriCorps, which had been subject to challenge by the 08/04/2025 PI motion

08/28/2025: OMB agrees to release FY2025 appropriated funds that it had held back from AmeriCorps, which had been subject to challenge by the 08/04/2025 PI motion

05/06/2025: Preliminary Injunction granted

06/03/2025: Second Preliminary Injunction granted

06/04/2025: Def. filed notice of interlocutory appeal to the Second Circuit.

06/10/2025: Def. notice of interlocutory appeal to the Second Circuit was DENIED

07/03/2025: Defendants file status report, asserting compliance with P.I.

06/03/2025: Second Preliminary Injunction granted

No. 25-1477 (1st Cir.)

Parties stipulated to convert the motion for TRO to a motion for a Preliminary Injunction

05/16/2025: Government appealed to the First Circuit

06/12/2025: Amended Complaint filed complaint

07/10/2025: Status conference held

07/15/2025: Joint Stipulation filed on behalf of the Plaintiff states on 07/15/2025 and entered on 07/16/2025.

08/11/2025: Status Report filed by Defendants, asserting compliance with the Preliminary Injunction

9/11/2025: 1st Cir. denies Government’s motion for a stay of the preliminary injunction pending appeal.”

4/14/2025: Amended Complaint filed

5/5/2025 Plaintiffs filed Reply to Response to Motion for P.I.

06/24/2025: Motion for Stay Pending Appeal denied

07/02/2025: Updated ruling in favor of Plaintiffs, reinstating grants as to the Plaintiff states (per CASA precedent) and Defendants file Appeal

07/18/2025: Defendant Motion for a Stay Pending Appeal rejected and District Court ruling reaffirmed

08/15/2025: Court order on Discover due

09/02/2025: Final Pretrial Conference and oral arguments on Motion to Dismiss

09/15/2025: Bench trial completion deadline

08/21/2025: Preliminary injunction stayed by SCOTUS.

06/18/2025: Hearing set for 11:30am

08/08/2025: Parties to file cross-motions for summary judgment

08/22/2025: Parties to respond to cross-motions

09/04/2025: Hearing

02/08/2025: Won a TRO

02/21/2025: Won a preliminary injunction

03/10/2025: The government moved to partially dissolve the TRO

03/12/2025: The states moved for reconsideration of the scope of the preliminary injunction

04/11/2025: The Court granted the government’s motion to partially dissolve the preliminary injunction as to one DOGE employee, and denied the States’ motion for reconsideration

05/01/2025: The government moved to fully dissolve the preliminary injunction

05/27/2025: The Court denied the government’s motion to dissolve the PI

07/28/2025: Defendants file Notice of Appeal to the Second Circuit on the Preliminary Injunction.

02/21/2025: Won a preliminary injunction

No. 25-1236 (1st Circuit)

02/12/2025: Order reaffirming Temporary Restraining

03/27/2025: Defendants’ Motion to Stay Preliminary Injunction Pending Appeal denied

04/04/2025: Plaintiffs’ Motion for Enforcement of Preliminary Injunction granted

04/07/2025: Motion for Enforcement of Preliminary Injunction is Stayed in light of Supreme Court decision in California v. Department of Education, the “”SEED grants”” case

04/28/2025: Appeal to the First Circuit Court is filed.”td>

Won a Motion to Enforce TRO on 2/10/2025

Won a preliminary injunction on 3/6/2025

09/24/2025: Scheduling Conference

No. 25-1248 (4th Circuit)

04/03/2025: Reduction-in-Force cases consolidated by Fourth Circuit

04/04/2025: Defendants’ motion for Stay Pending Appeal denied by District Court

04/09/2025: Defendants’ motion for Stay Pending Appeal granted by Fourth Circuit

04/01/2025: Won preliminary injunction

4/4/2025: The district court denied a motion to stay pending appeal

4/9/2025: 4th Circuit granted Defendants’ Motion for a Stay Pending Appeal

09/08/2025: 4th Circuit reversed the grant of preliminary injunction

No. 25-1343 (1st Circuit)

04/08/2025: Defendants file Appeal of Permanent Injunction to First Circuit.

By consent, the preliminary injunction was converted to a permanent injunction on 4/4/2025.

No. 25-1170 (1st Circuit)

On March 13, the government appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Oral argument held before SCOTUS May 15 on propriety of national injunction

06/27/2025: The Supreme Court finds that nationwide injunctions are not permitted as a blanket practice because they have no historical analog. However the Court declines to rule on whether the particular concerns the states raised require a tailored remedy that extends beyond the plaintiff states. And thus, the Court leaves the door open to the possibility that this particular situation of the harms that befall a state and its residents when citizenship is a patchwork system may require more sweeping relief (up to and including an injunction that applies in all states).

07/25/2025: The District Court once again blocks the Birthright Citizenship EO in Ruling on Scope of the Preliminary Injunction, clarifies and reiterates that his relief is universal despite CASA decision.

07/25/2025: The District Court once again blocks the Birthright Citizenship EO in Ruling on Scope of the Preliminary Injunction, clarifies and reiterates that his relief is universal despite CASA decision.